1989 Robert Duvall Classic Named ‘Greatest Western Miniseries Ever Made’ Was Written as a John Wayne Movie
The classic 1989 Robert Duvall, Tommy Lee Jones, and Danny Glover show Lonesome Dove was just named the “Greatest Western Miniseries Ever Made.” That is a huge accomplishment for the legendary series, which was based on a story originally intended for a movie that was going to star John Wayne.
Who Just Named ‘Lonesome Dove’ the ‘Greatest Western Miniseries Ever Made’?
Throughout television history, some truly fantastic Western miniseries have been produced, including Hatfields & McCoys, 1883, Godless, and more. Despite that stiff competition, Screen Rant named Lonesome Dove the “Greatest Western Miniseries Ever Made” on November 18, 2026.
The four-episode series, which originally aired in February 1989, starred Robert Duvall, Tommy Lee Jones, Danny Glover, Diane Lane, Robert Urich, Frederic Forrest, D. B. Sweeney, Ricky Schroder, and Anjelica Huston. There are many reasons why Lonesome Dove is widely regarded as a masterpiece by Western fans. One of the most obvious is that it features stellar performances from that incredible cast. Another is that it looks absolutely stunning, especially for a show that was filmed in the 1980s.
Related: 2004 Series Ranked the ‘Best Western TV Show of All Time’ Was Originally Planned to Be Set in Ancient Rome
The best element of Lonesome Dove is its epic story, which focuses on ranchers who are inspired to launch a massive multi-state cattle drive and the dangers that result. Given that the series’ characters and plot are a huge reason why it is still beloved after several decades, it is fascinating to learn about its truly unusual origins.
How ‘Lonesome Dove’ Started as the Script for the Canceled John Wayne Movie ‘Streets of Laredo’
On October 24, 2025, Remind Magazine published an article that chronicled the unusual genesis of the story that inspired 1989’s Lonesome Dove. That outlet quoted Larry McMurtry explaining that in the early 1970s, he and Peter Bogdanovich co-wrote the script for a movie that was going to be titled Streets of Laredo. As he noted, the film was intended to star three legendary actors: John Wayne, James Stewart, and Henry Fonda.
“It was originally written about 1971 for John Wayne, James Stewart, and Henry Fonda, with Peter Bogdanovich, fresh from his triumph of The Last Picture Show, to direct. It was quite a good script, I think. The studios loved it.”
From the outside looking in, a project with a great script, an enthusiastic studio, and three bankable stars attached seems like a can’t-miss prospect. However, as McMurtry went on to explain, Wayne was unhappy with the role he was intended to portray and insisted on switching. Because a casting shuffle could never be agreed upon, the project was left in limbo for years.
“Wayne didn’t want to play the taciturn Woodrow. He wanted to play Gus, whom McMurtry calls ‘the poet.’ This block existed for years. And Henry Fonda came around, and James Stewart came around, and John Wayne did not come around. And he died. And Henry Fonda died. And it went into a long limbo.”
After two of the attached stars died and the film still wasn’t moving forward, McMurtry made the rare decision to buy back the rights to the script from the studio. Then, he took the story and adapted it into the 1985 novel Lonesome Dove, which won awards and became a hit. The book’s stellar reputation inspired CBS to approach the writer about adapting it into the miniseries that Western fans know and love today.
Next: 2004 Series Ranked the ‘Best Western TV Show of All Time’ Was Originally Planned to Be Set in Ancient Rome
